“Batman and Eagle”: Jason Todd’s Original Codename Proves Batman Never Wanted a Second Robin

Batman and Robin are one of the most classic comic duos in history – meaning that when DC replaced Bruce Wayne’s original sidekick, Dick Grayson, in the role, the move drew significant ire from fans. Some never fully accepted Jason Todd in the role; however, the truth is, neither Batman nor Jason intended for him to become the second Robin. Instead, Dick Grayson himself offered him the moniker and costume.

1984’s Batman #368 opens with Bruce and Jason facing the dilemma of what the boy’s vigilante codename should be. Bruce offers up ‘Wonder Boy,” leading Jason to propose several alternatives. What’s clear is that, in the moment, Robin was reserved solely for Dick Grayson, even if Batman previously fired him from the role.

Later in the issue, Grayson is precisely the person who arrives to pass it on, along with assuring both his mentor and replacement that Jason isn’t “stealing his identity.”

Dick Grayson Chose to Pass On The “Robin” Title

Batman #368 – Written By Doug Moench; Art By Don Newton, & Adrienne Roy

The exchange makes it clear that Batman did not consider Robin to be his to pass down, but his first protege turned the role into a legacy. Dick Grayson is one of the most beloved characters in the DC Universe, and while he went on to lead the Titans and establish a new identity, he created the entire concept of “Robin” to be at Batman’s side. Bringing Jason Todd into the fold after Dick left wasn’t a smooth transition, and it’s evident that even Bruce and his new protege struggled with finding the right approach.

Though Jason took the role of Batman’s new partner and even had a suit with “Robin” colors, neither he nor Batman turned “Robin” into a title that was his for the taking. No one understands the significance of Robin like Dick Grayson, however, and he knew that nothing less would do. Robin is the balance Batman needs, like a light in the darkness, and it was at Dick’s insistence that both the name and the costume carried on without him. Regardless of how anyone else viewed him, he believed Jason was worthy of that honor, bestowing it on him personally.

Robin’s Continued Prominence Is A Tribute To The Original

Dick Grayson Defined The Modern Sidekick

Dick Grayson’s sidekick days with Batman may not have ended the way he wanted them to, but that didn’t stop him from recognizing the importance of Bruce having the right partner. He realized that Robin was essential to the mission of the Caped Crusader, on a symbolic level, even before Bruce Wayne did. As a result, Robin is a critical part of the DC Universe, and the Batman mythos to this day, making Dick even more pivotal to the legacy of all sidekicks than he might at first appear.

Several others went on to hold the title, and all of them did so in Grayson’s footsteps. His influence is clear, even in those he didn’t have a direct hand in guiding. It’s difficult to separate the idea of Robin from Batman, but it is a unique role – one that was created and shaped by the first person to use the name. Robin has been at the Caped Crusader’s side for decades, and that continued success is the perfect tribute to the original. Batman is a better hero with a partner, and Dick Grayson ensured it would always be Robin.